Baki Gaiden: Scarface is a supplementary story that diverges from the main Baki series. While it attempts to explore the character of Hanayama, it falls short in several aspects. Here’s a breakdown of its strengths and weaknesses: Lack of Relevance to the Main Storyline: One of the primary issues with Scarface is its lack of impact on the overarching Baki universe. Unlike other gaiden stories that enrich our understanding of characters or events, this one feels disconnected. It doesn’t contribute significantly to the main plot, leaving me wondering why it exists. Forced and Experimental: Scarface feels forced and experimental. The writing tries too hard to impress, resulting in adisjointed narrative. It’s as if the creators wanted to explore Hanayama’s strength but struggled to find a compelling angle.

Art and Writing Quality:

While we acknowledge that Scarface isn’t penned by Itagaki, the drop in art quality is noticeable. The illustrations lack the dynamic energy we associate with the Baki series. Similarly, the writing falls short of the usual standards. It’s a missed opportunity to showcase Hanayama’s character depth.

Cash Grab or Genuine Exploration?

It feels like a cash grab rather than a sincere attempt to enhance the Baki universe.

Final Verdict: Disappointment

In summary, Baki Gaiden: Scarface disappoints due to its lack of relevance, forced execution, and subpar quality. Still a classic, must read tho if you are a fellow Baki fan.