Story: 9/10. I know this is based of a video game but we are talking anime here- almost each and every episode is fun to watch. The subtle humor and the eagerness of Uzuki makes this show more entertaining to watch. The concept of a producer making the girls' dreams come true by helping them become idols performing on stage sounds fun and challenging at the same time. I don't see much dullness overall in each episode. Characters: 9.5/10 Uzuki Shimamura is the best girl, followed up by Rin and Mio. All characters in the anime have unique personalities and they are supportive of eachother which is satisfying for the viewer like me. Producer-san has a good heart and cares for the girls. Everyone in the anime is likeable, so I pretty much don't see any reason to dislike them.
OST: 9/10. Music is great, not much to say.
Art: 8/10. Art style looks dated but the complex animations such as the girls dancing are well animated.
Overall 9/10. I love it.
Its an underrated anime in my opinion. I was hoping for more episodes but it is what it is. I would never thought I would fall in love with this anime and demand more from the Cinderella Girls series so much.. again this is based off a video game, but good job A-1 Pictures for adapting this series very well. I recommend it if you are a fan of idols and a bit of drama added to the mix.