For me just rating shows that don't appeal to the general public, that are more specific to a certain audience has to be done differently. I am sure most people wouldn't consider this to be that good, but this is my first idol anime, and i can't believe how much i enjoyed it! The art is outstanding, the world is glittering and shining and the girls look incredible, the sound design is great and the songs are decent (i would've loved a bit more songs tho). All in all, even if you're not into idol anime, like i was, thismight be just the one to pull you over to the "dark side"!