Try Knights · review
Objectively speaking, not very good, especially the animation quality is pretty terrible. However. I was really entertained by how the rival school is going full on into LARPing territory with their shtick. You know how some anime will have "the prince of the school" or something? This school has a rugby club leader they treat like a prince (one guy would likely do anything for his sake, and frequently gets down on his knees to like, just give him a towel) and their club room has a large round table they all gather around, and it's located presumably in the Sistine chapel, if the decorationis anything to go by. It's ridiculous and over-the-top, I love it.
There's also a fascinating character that I cannot believe comes from this anime, and I know he'd get a bunch of fanart with angels and hell-like backgrounds if he was from a better anime.
Watch with a friend and prepare for something silly to have a good time with this.