I have given this manga a rating of 6. It deals with some fairly cliched themes, and being a short one-shot, it doesn't have the time for intensive character development or elaborate plot twists. It stays true to the formula and delivers a short sweet love story about an out of luck boy who thinks he will never be able to date a girl and a hardworking girl who is willing to look beyond the appearance of her partner. In my opinion, this manga has nothing special or unique. It lacks something that sets it apart from other manga. But since it can be finished soquickly, it is worth reading it to while away some time.