Review of Arakawa Under the Bridge
5.0/10 _____________________________________________________________________________________________________ There are certain tropes that exist within the realm of anime, well, less obviously, comedy anime. Said tropes seem to inhabit the majority of these programs and, to my dismay, negatively influence my enjoyment of these products. Tropes are not inherently bad, as they are a kind of backbone for every piece of entertainment. However, certain tropes you, as a viewer, can grow to harbor an inner disdain for. Comedy anime, especially of the romantic nature, tends to exude and indulge in these tropes to the point where they instantly put me off of a show. One of said tropes is the idea that ourprotagonist needs to have some kind of moral or ethical restriction or rule imposed upon them by nothing but their own will or experience, which often rings hollow since it is such a preposterous idea, to begin with. This trope, I'll agree, is present in a lot of anime, especially Shounen action, but it also persists in comedy for no reason other than to create over-the-top situations, naturally.
This is just one of those tropes that always rubs me the wrong way because it never breeds situations that I believe or find funny, and while comedy is generally unbelievable, there does need to be an air of verisimilitude that inhabits the scene for it to work in context.
With this knowledge, we enter "Arakawa Under the Bridge".
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
[Character, Delivery, Execution]
The trope here is utilized of course. Our protagonist, Kou Ichinomiya, kindly nick-named "Rec" or "Recruit" early on in the series, is a rich business elite who grew up with a tough, no-frills father that seemed to not care much about him at all. He taught him one lesson, to never take favors from anyone as you never want to be indebted.
So here stands Rec, on a bridge, pantsless, and wondering what he did to deserve to be stripped by a group of schoolboys. Here comes Nino, fishing his pants up from a hanging railing and handing them over to him. At first he rejects her assistance but then comes around to accepting her favor and is therefore forced to become indebted to her. She asks him to be her lover and well... you can probably guess where this goes. He is forced to be the lover of this surprisingly attractive strange girl who lives under the bridge. Woe is Rec.
Under the bridge, Rec meets a group of equally strange and zany characters that have all kinds of odd interests and hobbies. Ranging from a man in a Kappa costume who believes he's actually a Kappa, serving as the chieftain of this little group, to a man who is perpetually in love with Nino whilst also wearing a star-mask and making bad music. The designs here are all distinct and quite good, actually, specifically the gun-toting nun and peppy, yet clumsy farmer girl. This group of somewhat loveable and oafish characters don't get much development, as the series' thirteen episode stretch is more oriented around sketch comedy.
Unrelated skits backend each episode. These episodes are split up into multiple "chapters", each one signifying a different theme or concept and play out in one to ten-minute sketches that don't correlate with one another until the main psuedo-arc of the series comes into play. It's a cute format that is in-line with something like Nichijou, a favorite of mine. Unlike Nichijou, "Under the Bridge" doesn't have as much diversity or prowess in its execution, and unfortunately, a lot of the comedy falls flat. More on that later.
Ultimately, these colorful characters are not at all detailed enough, in my opinion. It's not like they have to be since there are plenty of comedy series' out there that don't have three-dimensional characters, but they make up for that in pure wit and amazing comedic chops. With "Under the Bridge", there is a specific effort for emotional moments and moments of actual romance, and unfortunately, they all fall flat.
Which is sad because the series is definitely at its best when it is being funny. Even if it isn't always funny. The first episode, also, doesn't feel like anything else in the series because it is substantially better paced and entertaining than anything else in this series, which is somewhat low on highlights and more just showing blips of inspiration a few moments of joy every episode.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
[Comedy in Anime]
Since I don't have too much to say about this series apart from "it's okay" and "occasionally funny" and "somewhat unremarkable", I rather focus on the broad experience I've had with comedy anime and the "style" is is often off-putting for me. I don't even think it is a cultural thing since there are plenty of anime that have had me laugh and there are plenty of Japanese films that are equally hilarious as some of the better productions coming out of Hollywood.
No, it's something more. It feels like so much comedy in this series, as well as a lot of the comedy anime I've seen hits the same way, with the same delivery, and the same kinds of shots and effects and even voice acting. Honestly, a lot of it seems very repetitive to an almost ludicrous level.
The same can be said for the way humor is handled at all. Jokes seem to go on for far too long, their punchlines run their course and instead of cutting, they either repeat the punchline or exposit the punchline, which makes it far too obvious and very clunky to sit through. It happens a lot. For example, a scene would lead up to a pretty decent punchline, and then, for no reason other than to explain to the viewer what is happening, the main character or whoever else would just yell out exactly what the punchline was.
This is what I call 'reactionary humor', where the writers try to add another moment of comedic timing and delivery through a character's reaction to the piece of comedy, however, it is so rarely funny. Especially since it is delivered the same way every damn time. It's always yelled loudly with a multi-colored background and action lines. It doesn't look good, it doesn't sound good, and quite honestly, it ruins the joke.
This problem persists throughout this series and throughout a lot of comedy anime because I guess a wacky face that I've seen a hundred times in a hundred different anime is enough to be a punchline now? So there's the problem, this odd, clashing style really detracts from the punchlines. I suppose it works for many, this very abrasive, loud, and reaction-based style of comedy. However, for me, it really doesn't do anything and "Under the Bridge" was brimming with it.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
[Aesthetic and Sound]
This is all solid. The SHAFT style is ever present. It feels a bit too much like Monogatari at times, but I suppose that style is what defines studio SHAFT at this point. It is especially jarring when the protagonist, Rec, is voiced by the same VA as Araragi from Monogatari.
The style here, while visually solid, isn't really necessary. I never felt the indulgent need for it, similar to Monogatari, and it very rarely actually affected the core of the show, which is the comedy. There are some pretty scenes, but in general, the entire show takes place in one, very green, very bridge-oriented location that isn't all too interesting after the first couple episodes.
The OP and ED are both solid, providing something that wasn't outstanding, but definitely is worth noting as a positive for this show's sound. Then again opening and endings in anime tend to blend together for me, so who am I to judge.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
[Conclusion]
It's okay. That's the best thing I can say about this series. There were stretches where I was bored and genuinely uninspired by what's happening on screen. There were moments where I enjoyed seeing these characters interact and seeing their little world grow, and there were, very rare moments of actual, laugh-out-loud comedy that was delivered well. Unfortunately, this makes for an unremarkable package that I don't see myself recommending to people who aren't already fans of anime-style reactionary comedy.
Describing this series, one of my friends called it "Monogatari-lite", and in a way, it is. The style is not as interesting, neither are the characters, or the setting, or anything, really, but the presentation is in line with what SHAFT has done with Monogatari and I, for the life of me, can't figure out why. There is no reason to include this kind of aesthetic in a show like this, and SHAFT shouldn't be pigeon-holed into over-relying on their developed style, which was pioneered by Shinbou. They are perfectly capable of utilizing something different like with Madoka Magica.
The music is solid, and the voice acting is generally really unremarkable. The most impressive voice work has to come from Chiwa Saito, who plays the cute young kid, Stella. Thi character is a brat and often changes metaphoric forms, which prompt the VA to have quite a few different inflections for this character that are not only endearing but are bordering on funny, too.
"Arakawa Under the Bridge" is a fairly unremarkable series wrapped up in the guise of something better. The style doesn't seem to fit, although it is visually pleasing, and everything from the story to the characters tends to flatline more so than anything else. Even if the characters themselves are well-designed. The attempts at romance fall completely flat due to the totally ridiculous premise, which fits the show's comedic tone but doesn't actually make for a believable romance or likable romantic prospects. The father/son relationship is a bit more interesting but honestly isn't explored enough to call well-done. Overall, it's "just there" as a series that I think doesn't do enough to actually maintain interest through the meat of its execution, which is the humor and characters.
The presentation is fine, although ill-fitting, and the music is decent, too. But ultimately, there's a dissonance between what works and what doesn't, and I will always find myself wishing that this series portrayed a more captivating world.