Idol X Idol Story! is introducing something new to the 2D idol sphere by bringing something that's common from the 3D idol world. As an idol fan, it's always exciting for me to see an element I often see with real idols being brought up in idol anime or manga. In this case, the plot of having idols going through an idol survival show where girls that have dreams of becoming idols are competing with each other to get a spot in the final group. There are a lot of potential from the premise alone. As idols that perform in groups, they have to work together andform bonds. Add the competitive element, and drama is bound to happen as well. All these facilitate character development and excitement for the plot.

Like many idol series, the story is character-driven. It has quite a big cast from the get go with everyone having unique traits. Unfortunately, the story can be a little bit rushed and some characters aren't developed enough, reducing the impact on some twists later on. However, it is something that gets better over time as each characters are slowly getting more and more of their story told, allowing readers to know and connect with them more.

The drama in this manga is executed pretty lightly, which can be a minus or a plus depending on individual taste. I personally expected heavier drama often seen in idol survival shows, so this manga can feel a bit dull at times with its more laid-back drama. However, it would probably be perfect for those who likes something that's more chill.

It's not the perfect idol manga, but it is bringing something new that touch upon a really prominent subject in the real idol world while still making it suitable for manga audience through its unique characters. It is worth a try for those who like idols - 2D and 3D alike - and CGDCT fans who is looking for just a little bit more spice from the usual relaxing fluffy slice of life. It is probably not for someone who is looking more into the world of real idol industry with a more serious and deep approach, nor it is for those looking for romance since the manga really focuses on the characters' dreams of becoming idols.