Because it was about the beautiful violin, I had to fall in love with it. The ghost element was also to my tastes and overall, I suppose I'm happy with the story, but I didn't feel an overwhelming love for it to put all manga love to shame. It's shoujo and supernatural, so I guess you can't expect it to make perfect sense, but I wish the author had made things a bit more clear. I loved the idea of "what if" and "regret", but the story isn't a downer, so it's not something to immediately doubt reading; there's a happy ending. It is aone-shot, so it's understandable why the author couldn't put more into the characters, but you can still understand how they thought.