Truthfully I had began reading this as an accident, but I can say it was quite a pleasant surprise. Initially I had some issues with the initial pacing of the story, as said in a few other reviews they skip over key information early. Some things such as why MC is a blacksmith in the first place are seldom explained. But outside of the beginning of the story I saw no real issues with pacing. Stylistically it seems rather standard for the period. I found they executed very common character cliches quite well. At the time of reading I wouldn't say there is a particularmain villain which you will either like or hate (personally I like it) saying that, there is no real shortage of action. The romantic aspect of the show isn't super complex, but also is far from the poorest execution I have seen. Also I'd like to say that the harem aspect of this story seemed rather forced.

If you are still undecided:

You MAY enjoy this if:
You normally enjoy power fantasy (even if you dislike otome I'd still give it a chance).
You enjoy slow-life type themes.
You like tsundere (they did it quite well imo)

You may NOT enjoy this if:
You are expecting something revolutionary (this is isekai go elsewhere).
You are looking for a well developed or well executed romantic plot.
You dislike the overusage of common tropes regardless of how they are executed.
You are looking for a story with a primary focus on power (its a theme throughout but doesn't seem to be the primary one)

Overall my personal rating (based off enjoyment) is at a 10. However the story has quite a few flaws that prevent it from being 'objectively good' (mind you im going by isekai standards) so I'd place it actually around a 6 or 7. If you decide to read this I have a feeling you may either really enjoy it or drop it incredibly early.