A Lustful Older Guy Took My Virginity · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

  • Most similar
  • Highest score
  • Most popular
  • Newest
    He Knows What I Do After Dark

    He Knows What I Do After Dark

    ★ 6.57 · 2017

    I Can't Do This Unless We're in Love!

    I Can't Do This Unless We're in Love!

    ★ 6.61 · 2016

    Escaping Paranoia

    Escaping Paranoia

    2021

    Unfaithful Love, A Thing of the Past

    Unfaithful Love, A Thing of the Past

    2018

    Love Me Or I'll Kick Your Ass!!!

    Love Me Or I'll Kick Your Ass!!!

    ★ 6.65 · 2017

    Let's Get Married, My Sweet Single Divorcee

    Let's Get Married, My Sweet Single Divorcee

    2018

    The 45-Year-Old Gentleman Is a Tactless Beast: Tonight, Teach Me How It's Supposed to Be Done...

    The 45-Year-Old Gentleman Is a Tactless Beast: Tonight, Teach Me How It's Supposed to Be Done...

    ★ 6.87 · 2019

    Dirty Dandies

    Dirty Dandies

    2019

    This Guy Says He'll Pay Me

    This Guy Says He'll Pay Me

    ★ 6.93 · 2019

    Sugar Baby in Bloom

    Sugar Baby in Bloom

    2017

    I'm an Incubus Who's No Good at What He Does

    I'm an Incubus Who's No Good at What He Does

    ★ 6.83 · 2020

    Bondage, Discipline, and the Seductive Young Man

    Bondage, Discipline, and the Seductive Young Man

    2016