First Time with the Boy Next-Door · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

  • Most similar
  • Highest score
  • Most popular
  • Newest
    Notice Me!: Best Friends Forever

    Notice Me!: Best Friends Forever

    2018

    Water Pillow Feather Pillow

    Water Pillow Feather Pillow

    1984

    Hachi/Ritsu

    Hachi/Ritsu

    —

    Can't Take My Eyes off of You

    Can't Take My Eyes off of You

    2016

    Lovestruck in High School

    Lovestruck in High School

    ★ 6.94 · 2018

    Asa made, Motto.

    Asa made, Motto.

    ★ 6.87 · 2005

    Natsuki Wants to Tease

    Natsuki Wants to Tease

    2022

    First Love Reset

    First Love Reset

    2018

    Sexy Gentleman's Superb Techniques: I'll Teach You How to be Sexy

    Sexy Gentleman's Superb Techniques: I'll Teach You How to be Sexy

    2016

    The Switch of First Love

    The Switch of First Love

    ★ 6.65 · 2011

    My Cute Little Kitten

    My Cute Little Kitten

    ★ 7.3 · 2017

    Two-Week Lover

    Two-Week Lover

    2017