My High School Romance · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

Sort by

Most similar
Highest score
Most popular
Newest

Love You Only

★ 6.44 · 2000

Secret Crush

★ 6.85 · 2015

The Man's Games

★ 6.85 · 2020

Swallowing My Darkest Desire

2023

My Secret XXX Fanfic

2024

Please take me

★ 6.7 · 2009

The Muse

2024

Gig of the Day

2024

Tipping Point

2024

I Got a Boy

2014

My Enemy Is My First Love

2024

Summer Sparks

2023