First Love Reunion: A Decade Later, My High School Crush Is Determined to Make Me His! · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

  • Most similar
  • Highest score
  • Most popular
  • Newest
    1/2 no Ringo

    1/2 no Ringo

    2005

    My Boy Possession

    My Boy Possession

    ★ 6.65 · 2000

    Here and There and Us (and Then and After)

    Here and There and Us (and Then and After)

    2019

    Sugar After Bitter

    Sugar After Bitter

    ★ 6.7 · 2021

    Douse Mou Nigerarenai

    Douse Mou Nigerarenai

    2014

    Gatcha Gacha

    Gatcha Gacha

    ★ 7.15 · 2001

    Let Me Listen to Your Heartbeat

    Let Me Listen to Your Heartbeat

    2024

    Dramatic Irony

    Dramatic Irony

    ★ 6.41 · 2016

    Cigarette Kisses

    Cigarette Kisses

    ★ 6.93 · 2007

    Undead Lovers

    Undead Lovers

    ★ 7.33 · 2013

    We are still in first love

    We are still in first love

    2024

    You're Mine

    You're Mine

    2010