Taken Captive by Two Former Classmates · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

Sort by

Most similar
Highest score
Most popular
Newest

A Lustful Older Guy Took My Virginity

2018

Taken by the Man of My Dreams

2021

Ani-Imo

★ 6.47 · 2012

The Second Sales Division!!

★ 7.64 · 2014

The Masked Tutor and Innocent Shut-In

2016

My Neighbor Is Devastatingly Sweet and Selfish

2021

Wayward Little Lamb

2017

Come On-a My House

2018

It's Their Long Story

2016

Fondness for Honey Melt

★ 6.66 · 2019

The Island of Dragons in Love

★ 6.45 · 2018

Steamy Influencer

2020