First Frost · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

  • Most similar
  • Highest score
  • Most popular
  • Newest
    First Love, Worst Love!

    First Love, Worst Love!

    2025

    Penthouse XXX

    Penthouse XXX

    ★ 6.93 · 2018

    Starting Over With the Dead You

    Starting Over With the Dead You

    2023

    How to Win Over Your Crush

    How to Win Over Your Crush

    ★ 6.85 · 2025

    My Exes Fell for Me

    My Exes Fell for Me

    2020

    Shining Summer

    Shining Summer

    2021

    First Love Reset

    First Love Reset

    2018

    Not Quite Love

    Not Quite Love

    ★ 7.54 · 2025

    I Want to Be Your Girl

    I Want to Be Your Girl

    2021

    I Just Can't Quit My Ex

    I Just Can't Quit My Ex

    2024

    Falling for It

    Falling for It

    ★ 7.31 · 2025

    My First Love With You Again

    My First Love With You Again

    ★ 7.08 · 2023