Substitute Boyfriend · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

  • Most similar
  • Highest score
  • Most popular
  • Newest
    1 Plus 1

    1 Plus 1

    ★ 7.0 · 2019

    The Commencement of Us

    The Commencement of Us

    2024

    My High School Romance

    My High School Romance

    2018

    Eighth Time's the Charm

    Eighth Time's the Charm

    2023

    Maybe Mine

    Maybe Mine

    2022

    I Love You, Until Morning.

    I Love You, Until Morning.

    2020

    Colored With Time

    Colored With Time

    2022

    Longtime Lovers

    Longtime Lovers

    ★ 5.87 · 2006

    Noise From Upstairs

    Noise From Upstairs

    2021

    His House

    His House

    2014

    Pure Intentions

    Pure Intentions

    2024

    Stealing Each Other's Lovers

    Stealing Each Other's Lovers

    2023