Prey · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

  • Most similar
  • Highest score
  • Most popular
  • Newest
    Taste of Illness

    Taste of Illness

    ★ 7.77 · 2018

    As the Heart Leads

    As the Heart Leads

    2020

    As the Heart Leads

    As the Heart Leads

    ★ 7.83 · 2024

    Shaman

    Shaman

    2021

    Rebirth in Paradise

    Rebirth in Paradise

    2020

    Pinocchio

    Pinocchio

    ★ 7.81 · 2011

    Find My Crown

    Find My Crown

    2024

    Otherside Picnic

    Otherside Picnic

    ★ 8.42 · 2017

    Onigiri Sasa

    Onigiri Sasa

    ★ 5.91 · 2014

    Truth or Dare

    Truth or Dare

    ★ 7.46 · 2019

    From the Internet, Creepypasta

    From the Internet, Creepypasta

    2024

    The Shape-Shifting Witch's Kiss

    The Shape-Shifting Witch's Kiss

    ★ 6.49 · 2021