American Pie · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

  • Most similar
  • Highest score
  • Most popular
  • Newest
    Please Hold Me Tenderly

    Please Hold Me Tenderly

    ★ 6.6 · 2014

    Koi Ranman

    Koi Ranman

    2013

    Jupiter ni Onegai

    Jupiter ni Onegai

    2011

    Yamada Sansuke no Muda na Teikou Yamemashou

    Yamada Sansuke no Muda na Teikou Yamemashou

    1995

    Sorry, teacher

    Sorry, teacher

    2014

    Hatsukoi

    Hatsukoi

    ★ 7.08 · 2013

    A Pantyhose Like World

    A Pantyhose Like World

    ★ 6.84 · 2001

    Ore no Kanojo ga xxx wo Kitai shiteite Shoujiki Komaru

    Ore no Kanojo ga xxx wo Kitai shiteite Shoujiki Komaru

    ★ 7.02 · 2009

    Kowairo ni Somaru

    Kowairo ni Somaru

    ★ 6.47 · 2014

    Dame na Oneesan demo Suki da yo ne?

    Dame na Oneesan demo Suki da yo ne?

    ★ 6.18 · 2019

    Hoshikuzu to Hatsukoi: Hyakunen-sou Monogatari

    Hoshikuzu to Hatsukoi: Hyakunen-sou Monogatari

    2015

    The Lust Aquarium

    The Lust Aquarium

    ★ 6.28 · 2015