American Pie · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

  • Most similar
  • Highest score
  • Most popular
  • Newest
    Magical★Travel Boy

    Magical★Travel Boy

    ★ 6.87 · 1998

    Victory: Ai wa Katsu

    Victory: Ai wa Katsu

    1998

    Kiss My Blood

    Kiss My Blood

    2011

    Pinkscrap

    Pinkscrap

    ★ 6.53 · 2013

    please don't cry anymore, even if it is a dream.

    please don't cry anymore, even if it is a dream.

    ★ 6.56 · 2015

    Girigiri Junai Hakusho (Kari)

    Girigiri Junai Hakusho (Kari)

    2014

    Itou-san

    Itou-san

    ★ 7.06 · 2009

    Shitsuren Nikki

    Shitsuren Nikki

    2010

    Mirai no Koibito-tachi

    Mirai no Koibito-tachi

    1994

    Disproportionate Chocolate

    Disproportionate Chocolate

    ★ 6.68 · 2008

    Please Don't Be So Mean to Me, Teacher

    Please Don't Be So Mean to Me, Teacher

    ★ 6.39 · 2018

    We're also the best couple today

    We're also the best couple today

    2009