My First Time · more like this

If you stay for this, you'll stay for these

Editorially ranked, with reasoning.

  • Most similar
  • Highest score
  • Most popular
  • Newest
    Girl Versus Girl!

    Girl Versus Girl!

    2015

    Kimi shika Iranai

    Kimi shika Iranai

    ★ 6.82 · 1995

    Before Dawn

    Before Dawn

    2008

    The Gift of the Magi

    The Gift of the Magi

    ★ 7.46 · 2014

    Metamo Kiss

    Metamo Kiss

    ★ 7.11 · 2004

    Former Girl Idol, High School Hunk

    Former Girl Idol, High School Hunk

    2023

    Seibetsu ga Doushita!!

    Seibetsu ga Doushita!!

    2016

    Ossan ga Shougakusei

    Ossan ga Shougakusei

    2019

    Shounen no Hatsukoi wa Bishoujo ♂ deshita.

    Shounen no Hatsukoi wa Bishoujo ♂ deshita.

    ★ 6.61 · 2019

    Seitokaichou desu ga Josou Hajimemashita

    Seitokaichou desu ga Josou Hajimemashita

    ★ 6.61 · 2016

    Trap You

    Trap You

    2013

    Tensei Pandemic

    Tensei Pandemic

    ★ 6.48 · 2017